MacMillan was never so entertaining or Provocative as on this disc. Piano Concerto No. 2 is based on Scottish dances and MacMillan’s concern is to awake the Scots from the unreality of the twee heritage of a ‘sham nation’. The Bestiary is a Mussorgsky-like parade among zoo cages for full orchestra and organ. Marshall conjures up some very unchuchy sounds on the huge Bridgewater Hall instrument, especially for the bee and howling jackass.
The Times
In both works Wayne Marshall covers himself in glory, as, for that matter, does the BBC Philharmonic under the composer’s direction. The sound is superlative to match. MacMillan’s legion of admirers needn’t hold back.
Gramophone
Wayne Marshall’s performance is irresistible,. The work will simply blow your socks off! There is so much to hear; you’ll want to listen to it again and again…
The Organ
James MacMillan conducting brilliant performances of his own exhilarating variations for organ and orchestra and Piano Concerto
Gramophone 2006 Critic’s Choice
Review of A Scotch Bestiary:
The piece was certainly fun: riotous, at times cacophonous, wittily orchestrated and cleverly structured. It also brilliantly integrated the organ into the orchestra proper. All these things and more merged in the work’s second half, a crazy but exciting amalgram…
Los Angeles Daily News
MacMillan was never so entertaining or provocative as on this disc. Piano Concerto No. 2 is based on Scottish dances and MacMillan’s concern is to awake Scots from the unreality of the twee heritage of a ‘sham nation’. The Bestiary is a Mussorgsky-like parade among the zoo cages for full orchestra and organ. Marshall conjures some very unchurchy sounds on the huge Bridgewater Hall instrument, especially for the bee and howling jackass.
The Times
This is fun- two recent works from Scottish composer James MacMillan that make Sassnachs Wayne Marshall and the BBC Philharmonic trip the Highland Fling. A Scotch Bestiary is MacMillan’s Carnival of the Animals, flamboyantly scored for organ and orchestra, and a work where reference to Mussorgsky, Elgar, Wagner and Messiaen’s bird song are tossed into a fantastical stew.
Classic FM Magazine
It’s [A Scotch Bestiary] all brought off with tremendous zest by Wayne Marshall and the BBC Philharmonic under the composer’s direction; but they’re just as much at home in the contemplative, painfully affectionate parts of the concerto.
BBC Music Magazine