"... Hickox and the Northern Sinfonia bring the score alive...The treble Connor Burrowes is cast as martin, and the chorus of his fellow orphans is sung with vigour and a refreshingly un-cathedral-like sound by the Tees Valley Boys’ Choir. Burrowes has a sparkling voice and sings with great sensitivity ... the cast give good, well-characterized performances..."
Erica Jeal - Opera - December 1998
"...The opera’s lean score is of great simplicity and transparency, and these qualities plus this sympathetic performance lend it pathos and transform it inot a touching listening experience, especially in this fine recording featuring baritone Alan Opie as the Stranger and tenor Robin Leggate as Father Cornelius... Both groups of songs are more sophisticated in their dramatic and musicl ideas that Martin’s Lie and more tonally astringent... Judith Howarth and Robin Leggate are joined by pianist Malcolm Martineau in creating these chohesive, convincing performances..."
John Ardoin - Dallas Morning News - 28 June 1998
"...Hickox again directs with committe zeal, this time with the Northern Sinfonia and a small cast including Alan Opie and Matthew Best who bring the story convincingly to life."
Michael Dungan - Classical Ireland - Summer/Autumn 1999
Performance **** Sound ****
George Hall - BBC Music Magazine - July 1998
"...This world premiere British performance ... is excellent."
Daily Review - USA - 5 May 1998
Timothy Ball - Classic CD - June 1998
"...The cast is excellent In the name part the boy treble Connor Burrowes delivering a remarkably marture performance as Martin... Richard Hickox conducts the robust voices of the Tees Valley Boys’ Choir and the Northern Sinfonia with befittingly innocent relish. To complete the disc, Leggate and Judith Howard sing two sets of poignant songs..."
SP - The Sunday Times - 26 April 1998
"...Warmly involving singing and playing. Judith Howarth and Robin Leggate are the singers in the two brief song cycles, with Menotti’s writing all the richer in the Italian settings." ****
The Guardian - 10 April 1998
"...The music is richly colorful, the characterisation lucid and succinct: this is a composer who makes every note tell. The accompanying songs make engaging listening ..." ****
The Scotsman - 3 April 1998